I remember the same chunk wanting Dan Twardzik signed up after his initial performances too.
As I said, I'm happy we extended his contract. It's more the absolutism of fans I take issue with where someone is absolute garbage or brilliant, without much room for nuance such as quality of players around them, overall form of the team and the fluctuations in performance that every player suffers.
I'd imagine any keeper would have struggled behind the joke of a defence we had last season.