1991

Thought Frear was great but has to be Aldred

Would never say Bowman was best striker at club, this has prob been the worst batch of strikers we have had in a long time. Johnson can finish but goes missing far to often. Main is a strange one seems to be underachieving dosnt score enough goals but like Bowman seems to give 100%. Sammon has proven he can score goals at this level, I would like to see him get a few games under his belt I know he is unpopular but he still managed goals for Thistle last year. James Scott, can't judge him maybe deserves a chance playing with Sammon to try something different

I liked Bowman but never thought he was good enough, always gives 100%. I have a feeling we might see Lee Erwin return

I feel I say this all the time but that is one of the worst games iv been at, left thinking i might not bother going on boxing day which isn't like me. I liked Robbo whoever I feel that is a result of the 2 cup finals. I think January is important get rid of guys like ATS and Sammon. I would even let Bowman go as I think we could get better. I know for every last min Celtic equaliser there is a St Mitten at home but that added with Livi away recently is a killer punch.

Who will get the job? Usually a promotion from exiting staff so prob McManus

Elliot Frear is terrible only winger who can't beat a man or cross the ball, he wasn't the only failure today but he brings nothing to the team especially when we have a fight on our hands. I also can't see why Johnson stayed on for 90mins it just wasn't his day today strange why Robbo took Main off

First time Robbo summer signing played a part. Gillespie: prob the first 2nd choice keeper we have had that is good enough, when you lose a keeper of Carson he looks a great addition when you look at guys like Griffths, Hollis and Neilson Mbulu: Looks like a real prospect, early to judge but looks like he adds pace and composure at back Rodriguiez: Did job asked when he came on to protect lead, not saying he is a first choice but good squad player Johnson: worked hard looked fitter and 2 good goals. Sammon will never stay beyond loan spell.

Grimshaw is a strange one, today he was superb and has been great the last few game (apart from rangers) I think today made me realise how valuable a player like him is to a team like us as he can play in so many position mostly defensive. I thought he would go at end of season but now I think he is a first team regular and if he continues he deserves a new deal. I felt the same in build up to cup final last year but he fell away at start of season. I think I may have written him off to soon.

Grimshaw was outstanding, no failures today great team performance

Good first half, unlucky not to be in front.

Enjoyed the game and performance. We desevered our win. Curtis Main badly needs a goal outside the box he was excellent but he just can't hit the target. Every player played their part but what I will say Is St Mitten are the worst SPL team I have saw in a long time. The two centre halves know Samson is a bombscare, no threat up front, only player who looks ok is Edwards. Wasn't impressed when I saw the team but fair play to Robinson he got it right tonight. What a difference when you actually see some football being played. What a farce the entry system is, that needs changed

At right mid with Tait behind him Cadden is great but as the manager plays players out of position his defensive responsibility takes away his attacking threat. I think he would be a massive loss.

I like Robbo but I'm not sure liking someone means I want him to continue as manager. I don't think anyone has enjoyed a game at Fir Park this season other than Rangers. Going to the game on a Saturday is meant to be what you look forward too but now I find myself just going as I have a season ticket. Did we have a shot on target in 2nd half I can't recall there keeper making a save. Let's start playing players in there position Tait at RB Cadden at attacking right mid. I don't think Frear is good enough but let's play him as a winger. Curtis Main needs dropped at the moment I would even consider Sammon before him, he still scored goals for a poor Thistle team last year. I know he isn't popular but can he be any worse than Main. If we get nothing from St Mirren and Dundee it's sad to say but he has to go.

2nd half was like Malpas was back in charge, we created nothing at all. I know Livi have started well but surely questions must be asked when we create 0 chances in that second half. I don't know what the answer is but I would like to see a 4 4 2 with Dunne at left back, Frear as winger Tait and Cadden on right. Bigi and Campbell in centre with Johnston and Bowman up top. I'm not wanting Robbo sacked but take away the cup runs the stats are terrible, something needs to change.

What has happend to Donnelly I don't recall seeing he was injured. That pitch is terrible worst iv saw, the pitch at the back of stand looked better surely something must be done look at the negative press we got with our sand pitch.

How Main lasted 90mins I will never know.; Then Frear again showing nothing I woukd rather Ross McLean was still here giving the chance Frear gets. When you need someone to dig deep Frear is never gonna be ur man

Poor performance but it's the first game of the season. First half was terrible. Worried Main dosnt look the same player. I think Bigi and Johnson must start next week along with Campbell. We played ok for the last 20 and could have scored a few but that's because Jibs allowed us to play and had the cigars out. Bad result but I'm sure we will improve next week.

I thought Rodriguez had a great game

I don't think it's a bad signing, I think he will do a job. I think he did well at Thistle until he had some personal problems. Scoring 10 goals for a team like Thistle isn't bad

Cheers African but doubt it, seems petty but when your 7 getting the new kit is a big deal he has had a season ticket since he was 4 so left the shop yesterday really disappointed

Really disappointed with shop asked if there was any possibility to get kit for my 7 year old kit at 8am on launch day as need to get my flight for holiday in Liverpool at 2pm, shop didn't seem interested at all was even gonna ask to ship to my hotel but felt they couldn't arsed

I thought the sub's Robbo made tonight won the game for us. Good 2nd half performance

Just phoned super score board venting my frustration no Alan Campbell

I presume Cifci can't play as he is on loan from Celtic

Carson by some distance for me. Went for Campbell over Kipre, very tough choice but as Campbell has came through the youth team I voted for him