Yorkyred

Obviously a choice that was always going to be debatable and we are taking the best of a very bad bunch here but he put in his usual shift in and tried to hold the ball up and play others in at times while just about everyone else seemed to just be thrashing the ball in any direction. Turnbull did have a promising debut but dare I say the votes are slightly skewed by the fact he’s a young player everyone has wanted in for ages. I’m also slightly biased as Bowman used to play for my hometown club York.

As we left the stadium they were hanging around near the local fast food place.

Probably a long list of individuals but sadly no obvious quality candidates in Scotland that I can see just now.

Bowman for me.

Obviously Lasley

Sadly a game devoid of quality and any level of composure. The return of Dunn a big plus and I though a promising performance by Turnbull. We were the better of two poor teams first 60 minutes or so but as St Johnstone came more and more into it you just knew they would grab a winner. Not sure if it’s just confidence but Cadden and Campbell just seem to be going backwards and without their contribution we really struggle. Fair to say Frear would have been better staying at home today but that probably goes for most of the team. I would have started Johnstone ahead of Main but don’t agree Main is not trying, I actually think all of the players are putting a shift in, it’s not effort that’s the problem it’s quality. Today was a big day for Robinson i’m afraid and to be still without a home win leaves him on dodgy ground. Real pity but every manager is judged on results so we need at least one win out of the next two or I feel the board may pull the plug.

Sorry but if anyone on our books is a natural goalscorer it’s Johnson. He’s shown that well before he even joined us.

With any young players timing is key. Bring them in too soon and you risk destroying their confidence and they go backwards. However it’s what people have been asking for and it looks like it’s now going to start happening so hopefully they are able to make that step up. They are going to make mistakes and find it tough at times but hopefully fans don’t get on their backs and give them time.

Honestly I would hope you’re right but sadly it’s a fact that a lack of patience and knee jerk reactions are a part of modern football. It’s also a fact that the majority of new managers fail and no one on here is actually able to name anyone they would like to see replace him which says a lot about the quality of any potential replacements. I still think the double blow of Kipre leaving and Dunne’s injury has had a huge impact this season regardless of formation or summer recruitment. It’s a fine line between success and failure in this division for the majority of clubs on smaller budgets.

It’s a long list of very poor looking options in my view. Robbie Neilson would probably have been in with a good shout but who else who is out of work looks like a good shot ? Other than that it’s going down the foreign route which is a huge risk, looking to England again, or poaching someone already in place but even then I can’t see a stand out candidate who would actually be interested. It would probably end up being Keith. Of course we may see a freed up Scotland manager shortly.

If we lose the next two he’s probably going to be sacked anyway. Hopefully he can turn it around, still think he has it in him.

Something like 18 years with the club. I would describe that line as highly insulting, he needs to show a bit more class.

Really, it reads like a 14 year old with 10 minutes to spare. I’m struggling to see how that could ever be described as an “ Excellent piece”.

Surely it’s first and foremost to pay off the debt and move forward from there. I would hope we will then see further investment in the playing squad and a better standard of footballer. Let’s be honest while we carry on signing none league, and lower league players from England we’re relying on a lot of luck because a percentage just won’t make the step up. Looking at who we signed this summer we have hardly pushed the boat out.

Not sure what Burrows being or not being a big fan has to do with anything. He’s got to make an educated business decision and look first and foremost in trying to keep us up every season, he should not be letting emotion get in the way. If he thinks Robinson can do that he will stick with him but he’s going to be more than aware that most management changes end up failures. We’ve had a few in a fairly short period of time ourselves.

Today was awful, no argument against that i’m afraid and let’s be honest we all thought it would be. Bit of a must win game for me because as evidenced by the feedback on here it’s obvious the tide was going to turn against Robinson otherwise. What do we do now ? i’m guessing he will get the St Johnstone game and anything other than a win and he will be out ( yes I know many want him gone now). Very sad after last seasons n but it’s results based and we just are not achieving enough points. However getting no rid is a risk, if he goes it’s nearly certainly going to be Lasley with no experience while Robinson has turned things around before. Big decision to make given what’s at stake.

Bigi does not deserve to keep his place after performances of late, I would hardly say that makes him the fall guy, Cadden was dropped for the same reason along with both Campbell and Rose. Bigi is not immune simply because he’s a bit of a crowd favourite and can pass a ball. Every single player in today’s starting line up apart from Carson has been dropped at one stage or another.

I’ve never been big on blaming refs for results so dissapointed he’s going down that line. Good teams pick up more points than poor ones, nothing to do with refs over the course of a season and the simple fact is we have not been good enough. I don’t see him changing the system or style of play, we will probably see Bigi dropped and Rose back in and back to playing less football but just now I don’t personally care how we play as long as we get the three points. It’s not going to be pretty and I think very frustrating to watch. God help us if they score first.

Because the vast majority are seeing the bigger picture and not knee jerk reactions. One or two on here have never taken to Robinson regardless of results, stated we would be relegated last season if he was not sacked and are stating the same this season. I don’t even believe all his summer signings are sh@te, they need time. Gorrin is a prime example of a player that if given that time could be a very good addition, he clearly has a level of technical ability and can pass a ball. Back up goalkeeper solid, Johnson very able and should get better, Aldred we already know about.

Because not going to games this early in the season is really going to help things.

It’s hardly an excuse, if you have a run of games against the strongest teams in the league you can expect in general to pick up less points than a run of games against bottom six level teams. Picking out exceptions does not change the overall truth of that.

I though yesterday’s post match interview by Robinson was a bit of an eye opener. Never seen him look so downbeat and for the first time he had a real go at the players and the loyalty he has shown. He’s clearly now feeling the pressure and probably for the first time knows he’s at risk of being sacked. As others have said three crucial games coming up as he acknowledged himself and without 4 points minimum he could go. Without doubt Saturday against Livy is huge simply to try and start building confidence against within the squad because when that drops to a certain level it’s very difficult to get it back.

You might go and support Celtic.

Anybody but Robinson ? Whoever it is you will be the first one on here wanting them sacked.

Thank god