wellsince75

This may be a little brutal, I don't believe Maguire is good enough. He's now 24 and played 50 games. Personal view is he's limited. Not sold we should have renewed his contract. Think he'll end up being a decent championship player similar to many young well starlets who didn't quite hit the mark. Dean though has a chance of making it. 21 and learning all the time, good prospect of becoming a decent player and for sure would benefit from someone like Davis talking him through games.

Agree - Lamie has too many brain farts during games. 90% solid but too often very lax and causes problems. I'd much rather bring in someone like McCart from StJohnstone who's out of contract. Prob the type of player we can afford and has proven to be decent.

signings are difficult - most of the time it's an underwhelming feeling - would really need to see a list of players we can afford - albeit that could be depressing. Unless able to bring back one of our previous hero's it's often likely to feel shit. Our best chance of having quality is brining them up through the youth system,

every defender in the team has deserved some criticism. It can't help to chop and change as often as we do. Get a settled back 4/5 in place. We need at least a very decent left back and ideally one very good central defender.

out of all the players leaving he's the one I've got a soft spot for. Appreciate he needs to move on and not the best player we've ever had but his attitude and effort was immense.

really good update , glad we're not offering extended contracts to the many of who've been around and not been quite good enough for a first team spot. I think Lamie has proven to be better than the other central defenders (not saying much). Also hope we help some of the others find new clubs eg. Carrol/Mcginley/Ojala/Solhom. Maybe even Woolery/Efford. I've seen enough of them all to wish them a happy start elsewhere

I agree we need a new spine right the way through- equally I'd like to see us look beyond the 4-3-3 formation and play to individual strengths. S'OD and Carrol for example both struggle to defend but both are blooming decent in the final 1/3. Tierney is a dangerous player but he isn't a striker nor defender - play him in the hole just behind. Overall yes we need to improve and bring in better than what we have.

Odds were never in our favour today . a decent Motherwell team often gets thumped by the old form . a team coming out of their sick bed was always going to struggle . a day for. 5-5-0 formation . happy to be 5th and somehow get into Europe

Some players make it easy to warm to them . Grimmie has a brilliant attitude and gave 100%. The few games that he did come in generated so much energy, he was a breath fresh air and could see his delight when he scored at Livi. Appreciate why he needs to move on, hope he gets a game time and finds a club that works for him.

The 2 big questions for me are 1) What have we achieved ? absolutely brilliant Graham, well done sir 2) how have we achieved it ? eye bleeding at times Graham, must improve. Job for this season done, please improve the 'how' next season.

great result. There is a great grit about the team with excellent fighting qualities. Lamie has really popped up with some very important goals for us, he may just stick around.

You Beauty ⚽️

clearly a sign that we'll play on the deck in future sessions rather than goofball

If they didn’t have people fighting for a place in the final I’d feel a lot more optimistic . hope we get stuck in and find a way to pull out the 3 points

very much agree. In truth we should let every player who's out of contract leave at the end of the season, don't think there's anyone who would be a certain start in first 11. It still leaves a huge amount of very average players on longer contracts - some creative wheeling and dealing needed to offload them as well. 3-4 quality players right through the spine of the team would make a massive difference.

Generally see a difference in tone and hoping the penny has dropped . we do the ugly side of the game really well. just give us something to cheer . Here’s hoping

Cracking result . unlikely to catch Utd but statistically still in it. Very odd season , it’s felt a hard slog yet here we are in 5th. like most of Scottish footy we need an injection of quality and good old entertainment . fingers crossed we can take a few more points

Not convinced that we should ever play both Efford and Shields together irrespective of injuries. Play 1 of them - Shields preferably and have an extra man in midfield.

Can't see anything changing - it's part of who he is, a hot head. If we was more consistent he would be with a bigger club than us commanding a very decent salary. Although frustrating I can't help but warm to him. A little bit like Ainsworth, on his day can do brilliant things but a frustrating bugger most of the time.

with injures we could try something completely bonkers - put woolery in as wingback and give him space to go charging up the flank. A 3-5-1-1 formation may suit us. Hope Tierney is fit - he's the one likely to get on the end of something.

He made a lot of sense when talking about the long term direction of the club and the fact that over the last 20-30 years we have had many periods where results were poor and we need to keep progressing. Good to see him being open, critical of himself for things he's got wrong and equally deserves credit from where we were last January.

really enjoyed the video and pleased to see people like Kerr, Hammel , Clarky all having influence in the future players. If they can find younger versions of themselves I'd be delighted

McCart has been excellent every time Ive seen him - I believe he's better than any defender we currently have . Suspect it depends on what happens with St.J come the end of the season. We must offer similar salary etc.

Suspect he's judged on what he's achieved v's how it's been achieved. He achieved top 6 - tick Had Aberdeen & Hibs delivered what's expected of them we wouldn't be top 6 and it would be questionable. I'd be happy to see us part ways but can't see us sacking a manger for being top 6 irrespective of any run of form /style of play.

Not GA's fault, he's not changed approach since day 1. The club extended GA - they saw the poor games each week but were delighted with the points. We were riding our luck big time in the first half of the season. Shame on them and not likely to change before xmas.