MJC

1-0 Dundee and no more than we deserve. Another pitiful performance and yet another early cup exit.

Fair enough then if that's the case, can't be helped. Half time 0-0 not much between the sides so far, could go either way.

I don’t think it is to be honest, most clubs communicate news about injuries and most certainly do about covid cases. If they are missing due to injury or covid related issues then fair enough, there’s nothing anyone can do about that but if they are simply dropped/rested and we lose then questions need to be asked of the selection decisions.

No van Veen or O’Donnell and Watt benched? I’ve not heard anything about them being injured or otherwise unavailable so I presume they have been dropped? If so and we don’t win this game then that’s a joke of a decision by the manager. I’m sick of us not taking Cup games seriously.

Our strongest team needs to start this one. No treating this as “just the league cup” or any nonsense like that. This is a must win game in a competition that we should be looking to go as far as possible in. Reckon we’ll sneak it 3-2.

Or “Punching way above our weight” in Latin or something.

He certainly did improve towards the tail end of the season, ironically enough when his ex Livi teammate Gallagher played less games. A coincidence perhaps but he looked an absolute bombscare for the first part of the season when alongside Gallagher in defence.

Amazingly he was. That was the most assured performance I’ve seen from him in a Motherwell jersey.

Full time 1-1. Happy with that to be honest. Not a great performance but getting our first point on the board for the season is important. A very well taken goal from Watt and but for a few cracking saves from Clark we could have sneaked it. Midfield and defence are still a major issue but it’s early days and we still have time to address those areas. All in all, a good result.

Campbell was basically our midfield last season and we haven’t replaced him. As has been said before several times already, we have nothing in the way of protection for our backline. Yaaaaass Watt!!!

Our lack of midfield options is again painfully evident here.

Another terrible goal to lose. A decent ball into the box and we concede, so simple and predictable.

Stating the obvious but we will need to defend a lot better than we did against Hibs to have any chance of getting anything here. St.J have shown over the past season that they are able to punish sides from set pieces whilst we have looked vulnerable at defending set pieces in that same time. We need to protect our backline and not make any rash challenges in and around our box otherwise I fear we will be undone again.

The problem with the midfield is that we are still extremely short in that area. No arguments about us being overrun and the defence having no protection but who do we put in there that will make much difference?

I don’t think O’Donnell has what it takes to play two positions at the same time tbh.

They beat us 3-0 going on six when we last played them in February at Fir Park. While there clearly were signs of encouragement to take from Sunday it is clear that we still have defensive concerns, something that was evident in the League Cup group games too. We need to learn to concentrate and ‘manage’ games better, otherwise we will continue to ship goals.

Our defensive frailties will cost us again here I reckon. 4-2 home win.

That is what I find unfair here. I’ve been generally supportive of restrictions and the Scottish governments handling of the pandemic but I fail to see how it can be deemed safer, in a Covid-safe sense, to allow people to cram into nightclubs where they will already be or will become drunk and inevitably drop their guard on social distancing than into a football ground which is more or less outside, with no alcohol on sale, sanitisation and cleanliness measures in place and numerous police/stewards in attendance to monitor the situation. I am as desperate as any to see the country get back to normal but I do feel that football fans have been dealt a tough hand on this one.

They are a decent side, not as good a side as their fans and the media would like them to be but they will almost certainly be top six at the very least this season. We showed today that we have the ability to compete with them over the course of 90 minutes but our defensive issues cost us again. As I said, I think Slattery will do extremely well for us once he’s up to speed and there were encouraging signs from Woolery and KvV yet again today.

That’s a sore one to take. By no means was that a poor performance from us, indeed we looked a lot more committed and up for it than we did at 90% of games last season. We matched a decent side well for the majority but unfortunately yet again our defending cost us dearly - their first two goals were down to shocking defending from us and we give away yet another penalty for the winner. We really need to work on defensive concentration. I think there clearly are signs of positivity but there’s still a lot of work, and hopefully transfer business to be done.

Can’t argue with the penalty decision when the arms out like that. We really don’t deserve to lose this game.

Lively stuff so far. Great to see van Veen get off the mark but a shocking goal to concede just minutes later. Either side could be ahead just now but I think we’ve just edged it and deserve our lead. When we actually play the ball on the deck in the middle we actually look like a football team - Slattery is going to be a great signing I reckon.

I’ve always viewed the Captain first and foremost as the player who is the leader on the park, someone who is vocal with the rest of the team and can when needed speak to/with the officials. Craigan, Lasley, Leitch, Phil O’Donnell and Tom Boyd are the type of guys that spring to mind when I think of that type of role, all guys who were able to be focal points of the team and who were the obvious ‘leader’.

Leadership on the field, that’s for starters and I think that is a key requirement for a club captain.

I would have had Kelly or Watt as captain ahead of O’Donnell that’s for sure. Be that just on the park rather than the ‘off the park’ matters, whatever they are, but I would have picked either one of them as leaders on the field before SO’D.