dont know if anyone has posted this so far as ive only been bothered to read the first page so far but , as much as it pains me to say it goodwillie is a more suitable choice for the scotland squad , because he is stronger , more agressive and a cocky little c**t and is more aggressive in getting the ball from his team mates i.e he will moan and moan and moan untill he gets the ball .
murphy is great for motherwell playing in a league when generally it doesnt get too physical , when it does he cant deal with it which was shown at rugby park , and at international level the centre backs are usually giants and imo at motherwell he isnt very vocal and at international level the players dont have time to look about and see him in a good position.
All my opinion , love murphy but at international level its goodwillie for me .
raging about james forrest but he's played a handful of games for celtic and suddenly he's international class