middleeastdave

Tut tut no Long, I thought he had an excellent game and don’t forget Gillespie who apart from a couple of saves did not put a foot wrong today (very secure)

I know I gave it to Mugabe the vote but that was based on being there watching the game and specifically the tackle he made on the St Mirren forward around the 35th minute , but after seeing the game on Alba I would change it to James Scott as I didn’t realise how well he took his goals, to be fair when you are sitting in the opposite end of the pitch from the goals you don’t get the full picture of the goals.

Very difficult not to give it to a Scott, but thought that Mugabe had just edged Scott with a brilliant game in the defence and I see why SR said that he reminds him of Kipre. To be fair to the team there wasn’t a weakness in the side tonight.

Any updates on Hastie or Camden compensation, I think we might get some money back on Camden eventually, but Hastie to me should be straight forward Rangers pay us for all the years of development, why is this taking so long, obviously waiting on Sevco going out of business again!!!

With the transfer window opening up in one month, do you think we need to do any business, with Dunne hopefully back and David Turnbull possibilities back Jan/Feb 2020? Personally I don’t think we will need to add to the squad unless there is a major injury in December.

Does anyone know when we have our AGM?

I know I will be in the minority but I would like to give Carson have a game against St Johnstone, I am certainly not blaming Gillespie for any of the goals lately but I just find that his distribution of the ball has been not the best and if we are going to loose Carson in the summer when his contract is up,( I cannot see him signing another contract from us) it might be a good idea to put him in the shop window as we might get some money for him in January?

I am not over confident, I know we should win this, but remember Dundee will be playing Competitive Championship football in January when we will be in Tenerife or wherever. as a matter of interest does anyone know when the last time there were no all premier league ties at this stage of the Scottish cup?

There was some good performances today despite the result but I thought Gallagher was immense

We definitely miss Donnolly today

Is he still alive?

There is talk of Alex Neil getting the Stoke City job, cannot see that happening if PNE are top of the Championship.

Sorry I am happy no players from us are in the big team, I hate to say all the players are getting tarred with the same brush at the moment and don’t think it will doing the players confidence any good.

I don’t know if anyone seen the goal, but it was supposed to be a cross into the box but was missed by everyone and into the net, any goal still counts. Any news on Getting compensation?

I originally asked if Gallagher would be good enough to play for Scotland and not sure myself but I think he is our best signing for a long time, I think he reads the game very well, his only question mark is his pace and can be caught out, but on saying that he is no worse than McKenna (who I don’t rate) or any other Scottish centre back that I have seen recently.

Don’t you think that Gallagher could do a job for Scotland?

After watching that shambolic (apart for first 15 mins) performance of Scotland last night, I was just thinking that the values of the “so called” superstars for us namely McBurnie £20m, Fraser supposed to be valued between £30-£40 m and even Robertson and I hate to think what his value is nowadays, so I am thinking that DT’s value of £3.25 m is a steal, I am probably biased but I just hope is value will be worth more when he returns?

Well that’s Killie snookered now!!

Do we really think he is that good? Hopefully I will be proved wrong, but I have to say his first 6 games were excellent, but clubs sussed him after that by out by putting two defenders on him which ended his threat, but to assess him on half a dozen games, I even think Sammon was supposed to be a class player when he started at Kilmarnock!! i still think we have signed the most potential player in David Turnball, so I am happy with that

As long as we are compensated handsomely I have no problem with Hastie taking Sevco deal, according to reports he has been offered £14,000 /week which we certainly could not even come close to match and is a no brainer for Hastie, especially for playing reserve games!!!

Very unfair question as Trevor has been a good keeper for us and through no blame on him he has this horrible DVT, but has to be said Mark has been just as good if not better in recent form. Rumour control reckons Trevor will not play again?

Have to agree Bigi I don’t think he will be greatly miss him and with us out the cup and a very outside chance of top 6 and hopefully relegation eliminated, we are quite rightly trimming the squad. What we need to do is get McGuire street wise as if Aberdeen rejected an offer of £5million for McKenna, McGuire potentially must be the same as can someone tell me why they value him over £5million as anytime I have seen him I didn’t think he was that good, although he did get picked for Scotland and had a decent game, so I assume his valuation is based on playing for Scotland!!

It will be interested to see how Dundee do now under JimMcIntyre, there is no doubt that McCann had lost the dressing room according to the rumours, I am also hearing that there is also some rumblings in our dressing room as well, from a pretty good source, but I wouldn't expect anything else the position we are in at the moment.

Both of them haven't been playing in the reserves (the Iron Bru Cup the exception) for a few weeks as they have been training with the first team, and that still didn't get them into the first team!!!!

I would imagine SR is under severe pressure at the moment and cannot see him taking any chances with any of our younger inexperienced players at the moment, but that may change especially if we get beat on a Saturday.