wellowell

You only miss next game if sent off in cup if violent conduct any other red stays for that tournament only .

FFS we've lost 2 games we normally lose as in Rangers home and Saints away and you have us losing 7 let's just wait and see what happens .

Bill Leckie wrong as would miss Aberdeen cup tie not next league game but we did appeal it yes so would have played on Saturday whether appealed or not

As we say football is all about opinions some think it's a red card some dont but for me neither argument is guaranteed as it's down to interpretation .

I wound expect Carson,s not to be overturned not because I think it's a goal scoring opportunity but because Dunne,s is a certainty to be overturned so if overturned 2 would show Thompson to be an incompetent twat and the SFA couldn't have that even though we all know he is .

Is this the Dundee that have lost to Ross County and Accies the 2 teams everybody tipped to struggle this season .

SJ2310 unfortunately I am crap with IT so not able to post rules but if you google triple whammy at penalty you will see new rule says got to be deliberatel foul if stopping goal scoring opportunity to be sent off if penalty given so you may think I'm wrong but I disagree as sure I'm right .

New rule say if penalty given their is no longer a double whammy as in pen and sending off . The only way you can be sent off is if you deliberately stop goal scoring opportunity so if you foul and even if last man and it's not deliberate it's now a yellow and a pen .I am 99.99 % certain Dunne red card will be overturned as never deliberate if he even fouled him in 1st place as that's debatable .

Just seen Dunne sending off never in a month of Sundays did he deliberately foul that guy Thompson obviously dosnt know the rules . Never seen enough to see if was penalty but certainly not deliberate and under new rules should have been booking at worst .

Were you there steelboy ?

+2

For it to be a red card it has to be deemed deliberate I think he tried to use his body to get in front of player but it's hard to prove he deliberately fouled him . I'm not saying was not a penalty but if be can prove he was genuinely trying to get ball then it's not a red .

I agree put McLean in no point in taking chances we have a squad this year so use it

No don't think so will be banned fir Aberdeen league cup game

Fior me Fisher,s link up play and all round effort been great just has to start doing the most important part which is scoring

Superb deal looking forward to the east stand queue being behind Phil o,donnell stand as game kicks off and before anyone else says it I know can arrive earlier but there's no chance of that happening .

They won't have made 2 million though if he goes for that as cost them 600K and if we get another 350K then we will have had 950K and they will be 1050K up so only 100K of a difference

Next league cup I'm sure only violent conduct is next game

Both on BT sports as well

Surely we will be on the Thursday then as playing Aberdeen on the Sunday again so would make sense ,surely they won't pick a Hibs romp against Livi

I'm sure last season 3 of the 4 Quarters were on Tv over Tuesday , Wednesday , and Thursday but may be wrong but agree if 1 or 2 on will be old firm .

It is

Superb victory to win after going down to 10 and we actually got a home draw wow

Yesssssss

Yea 4th sub now allowed if a game goes to extra time