Bloody hell, how this thread got into 4 pages in a day I will never know.
I would ask anyone reading this to consider the following points...
1. Frazzle is just one member of the Trust board. His viewpoint on here not the view of the Trust Board overall unless explicitly stated. I'm pretty sure there are 11 members of the board, including myself, AndyRoss, The Dossier and BK. Not everyone agrees with Frazzles viewpoint on this.
2. It has been identified by The Dossier on the email listing today that there had been confusion with our treasurer, hence the reason for the non payment of an agreed sum. However I understand that discussions did take place with regards to Terms & Conditions of the payment of the £200 this year.
3. The Trust has a problem of falling membership, no secrets, no smokescreens. The Trust board are commited to taking steps to reverse this trend and attract people to join. Whilst some people will accuse Frazzle of his stance because of his FPC job, I really believe his position on this matter is more down to the fact that the Trust Board have to consider carefully how every penny is spent so that the membership GROWS this year, not falls backward. My personal point of view is that funding WTFC from Trust coffers is not benefitial toward this goal. If we had a couple of people from the team sign up to the Trust then it would be benefitial and I would definetly be strongly in favour of financial support. Put simply, it's a numbers game. The club (MFC) will take less notice of the Trust with it's current membership than it did back at the start. As fatcalf mentioned but, there would be no way WTFC could demand their players sign up for the Trust so our two organisations need to work out a way we can help each other with our problems.
4. I wasn't in the Trust Board when the 2nd request for a donation came from JP. What I would say is that from a personal point of view, if it was a choice between Youth Development or helping JP out - it would be Youth Development every day of the week. My view is formed not because of a return to the Trust, but more from a return to the Club. I would rather the Trust spent money helping the club find the new James McFadden or Phil O'Donnell than helping JP do essentially what he is paid for. Also, from talking to other members of the Trust board, the donation request was not turned down because of anything to do with Logo's or Publicity, it was knocked back because it would have taken away at least 1/4 of the money the Trust has in it's account. It was suggested that the Trust could partially fund the equipment.
From the above I think it's clear that discussions need to take place between WTFC reps and MST reps so we can sort out this sorry mess. What I would say is that whilst some of Frazzle's comments have been wide of the mark, some of the abuse leveled back has been a mile out of order. If we are talking about working together then personal abuse gets you knowhere.