MelvinBragg

You said he had signed no attacking midfielders. If you're going to criticise him (and there's plenty to criticise him for), at least stick to facts...

He signed Nicholson...

Who have those two signed?

How much did we get for James Scott?

Stop coming here with facts...

A centre midfielder? Good luck with that. Paton, Miller, Zdravkovski, Halliday, Sparrow, Nicholson, Callaghan could all be classed as midfielders and Wells is coming through with Slattery to return. Whatever you think of their quality, that's a lot of wages already used up there...

Aye, Ruddy and Gillespie? Do you need two?

I assumed that meant Mark Gillespie had been released. But no...

If we sell Bair and Van Veen has lost about a stone. Then I'll maybe think about it. And even then I'm not convinced...

Looking at the squad, prayer might not be a bad idea...

Any word on a goalkeeper signing? Or are we going away for out preseason camp with only one goalie?

Whatever you think of their quality, I'd argue that Kettlewell has five players he considers central defenders so not certain another one will be close to the top of his list. Goalie definitely a priority. Wing backs we tend to source from English Premier League or Championship academies so we'll probably need to wait on that one...

Stupendous signing?

Or 6 in 25 if you include cup games. He's 21 and when in the Championship with Dundee scored more than one goal every three games. Not saying that he'll be good but you can pick your statistics to make a case either way...

I was replying to a post (and I think quoted it) that suggested the proposal was so bad that there was no need for a vote, the Society Board should just reject it. I wasn't suggesting there wouldn't be one...

What if the majority of Society members disagree with the board? Not that I think it's the case, but for such a big issue surely members have to have a vote..?

I'd argue the value of some of the assets isn't written in stone. What's the value of Fir Park? Whatever someone's willing to pay for it? Same applies to players. Value of future income? Well, how do you forecast that? We could do a Falkirk and disappear to League One. I'm not suggesting it's a fair value that's been assigned but I think it's very hard to state that there is a specific value that Motherwell Football Club is worth...

Calm down. The Well Society is a democracy, you would no doubt complain if they made a decision of this scale without consulting members. The Society board (well, the majority of them) are making it quite clear they disagree with the valuation. But it's right that members can make up their own minds. I think your criticism of the Well Society is quite harsh here. And I say that as someone without a dog in the fight as I'm not a member of the society...

Obviously you didn't read the article where they mentioned the inadequate valuation of the club as one of several reasons they were against the proposals..

Hard to disagree with that. Although I'm most interested in seeing who we bring in goalkeeper wise as it'll give an indication as to where Oxborough is first choice, second choice or competing with the other keeper...

He's young enough that hopefully he'll develop. And hard for anyone to shine on that junkie's carpet that Accies play on. Could be this season's Bair...

Is this you writing Sparrow off already?

Bevis wasn't the worst but he was the one out of contract. I think it may be as arbitrary as that. Because Casey and Blaney have the same weaknesses...

I don't there's much of a difference between Mugabi and Casey. Both solid 90% of the time but prone to errors. I think the main difference is that our fans have seen Mugabi making his mistakes for longer and so are less tolerant of him..

I think if you're looking for a bench mark for Bair, the fee we got for James Scott is a reasonable comparison. Both have the physical tools but both prone to missing chances they perhaps should take. Bair is older than Scott was when he left but inflation of prices since should make up for the age difference... That's my opinion anyway...