MelvinBragg

Best guess is the first option. Fearing it's the second...

Good news: if we don't know how Robinson is setting us up, chances are McIntyre won't. Bad news: there isn't a formation that doesn't look unbalanced... EDIT Will be interested to hear those at the game clear up exactly how we've set up...

Fans, like players, can often struggle for consistency early in the season.. While I am not rushing to label him as a bad signing, Andy Rose is the one that's impressed me the least. Not entirely sure what he contributes. But I haven't seen enough of him for me to write him off...

Player signs for Club A on loan but never plays due to an illness that player admits himself makes him unable to play in Scotland but not England. Player signs for club B. Club A and B are due to play and player isn't mentioned as being doubtful. Player doesn't play. These are conditions rife for speculation and rumour...

Or the issue only gets brought to light when another club who is already aware of it brings it up...

Worryingly you can easily find a Daily Record article where Bigirmana himself says that he had (at least when he signed for Rangers) an illness that wouldn't let him play under SFA rules but didn't prevent him playing in England. Are we going to find ourselves in a situation where a key summer signing isn't eligible to play..?

Given there are no real secrets in football, if this were the case and Rangers were aware of it, pretty sure we would have known about this before signing him. And if Rangers can somehow object, any team that we play against will do so...

Interested to hear a second person suggest Rangers somehow dictated that Bigirmana wouldn't play today. I'm not sure how that would even be possible?

No idea what that means...

Bad miss..?

Worse than Moult's?

For the benefit of those at work without a TV, who for?

Sounds intriguing...

No Bigirmana is a real concern. Still not sure what Andy Rose offers. Hopefully today he'll prove me wrong...

Undecided how today will go. I'm working and have a habit of missing our good results. But on the flipside, it's Rangers and we always seem to fuck up against them, no matter the quality of their team. Hoping for at the very least for a decent performance giving some degree of hope for the season ahead...

Thought Killie's goal was a direct free kick?

Kipré is young and may need taken out of the firing line at some point. Dunne has a chequered past injury wise as has Plummer. McManus and Hammell don't look capable of playing every week. We're actively looking to sell Heneghan. Last week our defensive midfielder ended up playing centre half. I'd say we might need another defender...

Could you argue that Higdon would get in the 91 team ahead of Ferguson?

I take your point about the manager already having seen him at close quarters. Argument could be made (and I reckon we won't sign him) that the manager has seen him and maybe thought he could find someone better but having looked around hasn't been able to get anyone. Possible.. Like I said though, one guy on twitter. I'll believe it when I see it confirmed...

This Plummer rumour seems based on one tweet. We do need a centre back and if he has trained with us previously then I suppose we may have made him an offer but there seem to be far more people linking him with Leeds. Doubt we could compete...

I think both teams looked poor. Allan flatters to deceive and Deacon looked like an Ainsworth without the end product. Obviously Dundee will absolutely destroy us when we play them because I've said this...

If Scott McDonald likes to moan and complain about team mates that aren't up to his standard, then on the evidence of the Dundee derby, he'll have plenty to moan about. Mind you, Dundee look don't look great either...

My prediction is a difficult away tie. Because it's the Motherwell way of things to be seeded and see a non seeded team get an easier draw. For example, would any of us be stunned to see Hamilton get Ayr Utd at home while we are away to Hibs...?

Who playing left midfield?

Not sure what to make of that lineup. Not sure who would play left midfield or left wing back in that setup. Honestly can't see a shape that makes sense. At a push.. Carson Tait Kipre Dunne Hammell Rose McHugh Bigirmana Cadden Moult Tanner