One of the most bonkers opinions I've seen on here in a long time.
Don't get me wrong, I think Murphy is a really good player when on his game, but he isnae a patch on McFadden when he was at Motherwell. Murphy is 21 now, but McFadden was a far more influential player in our side then and he was a full Scotland international at that stage, which I dont think Murphy is ready for, certainly physically.
Me and my mate have been watching him specifically all season, and in the 1st half of games he has been senastional at times, come the 2nd half he becomes non-existant in most games, whether thats through tiredness or opponents wising up to him but Faddy was dominating games and taking them by teh scruff of the neck at a younger age than Murphy is now.