success comes from winning trophies? so you wouldn't consider last season even finishing third under mclean as succesful seasons.
being bottom in december and then going for europe has to do with the level of parity in the league, a 20 team league would have whipping boys and it wouldn't be possible for a team to make up so much ground.
as for a top six match against aberdeen, it definitely floated my boat ten months ago.
i'd argue that scotland has different circumstances from pretty much every other major european league. with two teams soaking up most of the fans, our small population and the premiership on our doorstep (and on the bbc, sky, itv and setanta) which weakens our posistion further. if you were to split the little money we have across more teams it would probably mean from our point of view no porters, hughes or klimpls and it would make it harder to hold onto decent young players. how lessening the quality of teams is good for the national game i can't quite fathom.
accies and st mirren have shown that well run teams can get into the spl and survive and i don't think it's necessarily a bad thing that the first has st johnstone, dundee, partick and dundee fighting it out.