Hearts Man of the Match

[Andy_P]

Your thoughts and votes please... 

[texanwellfan]

Mchugh.  Ok his mistake cost us a point but most of the other performances also cost us that point. 

[weeyin]

If it hadn't been for his hospital pass to Carson, McHugh would have had my vote.

[MelvinBragg]

Curtis Main for making me believe I could still make it as a professional footballer...

[Ya Bezzer!]

Difficult one. 

Aldred and Tait gave their usual steady eddie performances.  Gillespie came in a made a couple of decent stops.  Bigi looked decent at times.

I'll go for Aldred.

[Yorkyred]

McHugh actually had a very good game blighted by one stupid hospital pass.

[Lobey_Dosser]

McHugh despite his costly mistake, that’s how mediocre the rest were. 

[steelboy]

McHugh cost us the game and possibly cost Carson a lot more. He played well but it's not the first time he's done something extremely stupid.

Aldred by a mile.

 

[wellup83]

Went for McHugh despite his mistake as I thought he bossed number 19 all game. A lot of players off the pace today sadly. 

[Pepper]

McHugh, bar his mistake, was outstanding today.

[Yorkyred]

27 minutes ago, steelboy said:

McHugh cost us the game and possibly cost Carson a lot more. He played well but it's not the first time he's done something extremely stupid.

Aldred by a mile.

 

Aldred by a mile ? All our central defenders have made mistakes this season yet it’s always McHugh who gets highlighted by some who simply can’t tolerate him. He’s been our best centre half by some way this season up to this point. I like Aldred and Hartley but McHugh has got us out of trouble a few times.

[MelvinBragg]

Aldred was garbage. Hearts kept allowing him to have the ball knowing they'd get it back soon enough...

[steelboy]

Our shitebag holding midfielder continually let him have the ball.

[Toxteth O'Grady]

McHugh absolutely strolled through the game. He gets my vote despite his error, mainly because there are so few other candidates.

[grizzlyg]

Defo mcshug.  Apart from goal was excellent. Campbell started well and I thought Gillespie done well

[Kmcalpin]

Null vote for me. Felt a bit sorry for our our strikers as they were up against a mountainous defence and received shocking service by and large. 

[ohwulliewullie]

Ah McHugh.... was doing great and did so again after the mistake. Think he’s been our best player this season so far too. Reads the play well, brave, and wins more than he should in the air 

[Welldaft Mk1]

Agree with most. His mistake was a bad one and will be rightly highlighted, but before and after he was our best player. As others have said you can pick up a few others as being as culpable from their general performance which was well below their capabilities. 

[Del_Superwell]

McHugh was very good before the mistake he made and will be very lucky if Carson isn't out for a considerable period of time,  he was decent after the mistake but he was also fault for the Dundee goal a couple weeks ago as well when he lost his man for a free header but that aside I will give him the benefit of the doubt.  I reckon the back 3 will look a lot a better and stronger when we get the pace of Charles Dunne back in there. 

[Ya Bezzer!]

17 hours ago, Yorkyred said:

Aldred by a mile ? All our central defenders have made mistakes this season yet it’s always McHugh who gets highlighted by some who simply can’t tolerate him. He’s been our best centre half by some way this season up to this point. I like Aldred and Hartley but McHugh has got us out of trouble a few times.

I'm much happier with McHugh at the back than in midfield but the last two games he's cost us two very poor goals.  That's why he's been 'highlighted'.

[weeyin]

2 hours ago, Ya Bezzer! said:

I'm much happier with McHugh at the back than in midfield but the last two games he's cost us two very poor goals.  That's why he's been 'highlighted'.

Aye, he's been guilty of what used to frustrate me about Stephen McManus. Would be extremely solid for 95% of the game then switch off for a minute and cost us a goal.

[daver]

Couldn't bring myself to vote for McHugh because of the game-changing mistake so went for Aldred.