livivoice Posted May 20, 2021 Report Share Posted May 20, 2021 Just a bunch of old guys who share their views at the end of each season. Helps to pass the day. Therefore not to be taken too seriously and certainly shouldn't warrant any abuse from anyone. We award points out of 10 for each player who started games. Not substitutes e.g Crawford who came on at Tannadice after only 6 minutes. 1. Campbell 185. 2. O'Donnell 177. 3. Gallagher 162. 4. Watt 138. 5. Lamie 137. 6. Cole/ O'Hara 121. 8. Mugabi 102. 9. Long 101. 10. Kelly 96. 11. Polworth 93. 12. Crawford 86. 13. Carson 81. 14. Mc Ginley 78. 15. Grimshaw 60. 16. Maguire 56. 17. Carroll 55. 18. Magliore 35. 19. Roberts 30. 20. Hastie 27. 21. Seedorf 26 22. Lawless 23. 23. Chapman 17 . 24. Foley 15. 25 . Donnelly/ Johnston 4. Other players; Lang 61. Turnbull 27. Archer 15. White 13. So, there you go. Not to many surprises with Campbell winning quite comfortably. Then again SOD if he had signed at the start of the season may have pushed him close. Also Watt and Carson would have been much higher but for injuries . Many will question meantime how some of the players got awarded any points!!! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Spiderpig Posted May 20, 2021 Report Share Posted May 20, 2021 45 minutes ago, livivoice said: Just a bunch of old guys who share their views at the end of each season. Helps to pass the day. Therefore not to be taken too seriously and certainly shouldn't warrant any abuse from anyone. We award points out of 10 for each player who started games. Not substitutes e.g Crawford who came on at Tannadice after only 6 minutes. 1. Campbell 185. 2. O'Donnell 177. 3. Gallagher 162. 4. Watt 138. 5. Lamie 137. 6. Cole/ O'Hara 121. 8. Mugabi 102. 9. Long 101. 10. Kelly 96. 11. Polworth 93. 12. Crawford 86. 13. Carson 81. 14. Mc Ginley 78. 15. Grimshaw 60. 16. Maguire 56. 17. Carroll 55. 18. Magliore 35. 19. Roberts 30. 20. Hastie 27. 21. Seedorf 26 22. Lawless 23. 23. Chapman 17 . 24. Foley 15. 25 . Donnelly/ Johnston 4. Other players; Lang 61. Turnbull 27. Archer 15. White 13. So, there you go. Not to many surprises with Campbell winning quite comfortably. Then again SOD if he had signed at the start of the season may have pushed him close. Also Watt and Carson would have been much higher but for injuries . Many will question meantime how some of the players got awarded any points!!! I see Lawless is below Seedorf a fair assumption of his suitability for the premiership if you ask me Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SteelmaninOZ Posted May 20, 2021 Report Share Posted May 20, 2021 14 hours ago, livivoice said: Just a bunch of old guys who share their views at the end of each season. Helps to pass the day. Therefore not to be taken too seriously and certainly shouldn't warrant any abuse from anyone. We award points out of 10 for each player who started games. Not substitutes e.g Crawford who came on at Tannadice after only 6 minutes. 1. Campbell 185. 2. O'Donnell 177. 3. Gallagher 162. 4. Watt 138. 5. Lamie 137. 6. Cole/ O'Hara 121. 8. Mugabi 102. 9. Long 101. 10. Kelly 96. 11. Polworth 93. 12. Crawford 86. 13. Carson 81. 14. Mc Ginley 78. 15. Grimshaw 60. 16. Maguire 56. 17. Carroll 55. 18. Magliore 35. 19. Roberts 30. 20. Hastie 27. 21. Seedorf 26 22. Lawless 23. 23. Chapman 17 . 24. Foley 15. 25 . Donnelly/ Johnston 4. Other players; Lang 61. Turnbull 27. Archer 15. White 13. So, there you go. Not to many surprises with Campbell winning quite comfortably. Then again SOD if he had signed at the start of the season may have pushed him close. Also Watt and Carson would have been much higher but for injuries . Many will question meantime how some of the players got awarded any points!!! Good bunch of old guys you have there livi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.