2024/25 Ins & Outs Discussion

[weeyin]

11 minutes ago, texanwellfan said:

Maybe not right away if he went to Norwich but possibly after a year or two and with a bigger better club than Celtic but we’ll never know now. 

It's tough.

John McGinn has been one of the more successful Scottish exports, but his trophy wins are with St Mirren and Hibs. I suspect he's enjoying himself at Villa more than he would have enjoyed himself at Celtic, but only he can say for sure if that's true.

[Richie]

Turnbull had a tremendous fisty half-season at Celtic.

Then injuries and Ange Postecoglu's high tempo pressing game didn't really suit him.

[wellgirl]

Apparently Udinese have had two offers knocked back and are going to make an improved one for Miller 

[texanwellfan]

13 minutes ago, Richie said:

Turnbull had a tremendous fisty half-season at Celtic.

Then injuries and Ange Postecoglu's high tempo pressing game didn't really suit him.

Obviously up to each individual and it’s always nice to win medals and trophies but winning honours with Celtic in Scotland is a bit empty. They could throw one of us in from off here and we’d win medals. 

[mio]

1 hour ago, weeyin said:

Ultimately, it's down to what motivates individual players - and even that might change at different stages of a career.

 

 

 

 

Also it depends who wants to pay the most. Celtic offered more than Norwich or any other club. the sale ultimately benefited Motherwell more than it did Turnbull.

[0Neils40yarder]

On 1/21/2025 at 3:20 PM, Spit_It_Out said:

Pretty shocked a really big club hasn't came in for Lennon Miller i mean if we are looking for say 4-5 million thats next to nothing for even the Aston Villas and such of the world.

Surely they have seen enough to say yep get this boy in and we shall get our money back on him at the very least if it doesn't pan out.

Maybe he's slightly over-hyped (or well marketed) by the club?

3 hours ago, mio said:

I do know what you sort of mean with Turnbull but let’s be fair, he went to them and won 2 titles, 2 Scottish cups and 2 league cups and also played in an environment which demanded winning on a weekly basis, playing in front of 60000 people and regular champions league matches.  He wouldn’t have got that at Norwich.

hes been very unlucky with injuries(as seems to be the case at the moment as well) if it wasn’t for injuries im sure he’d have been in a better place just now and still be around the Scotland squad.

He made a dreadful decision going to Parkhead, a club that really doesn't fancy playing many young Scots when it matters

1 hour ago, wellgirl said:

Apparently Udinese have had two offers knocked back and are going to make an improved one for Miller 

Hopefully the club know what they are doing...its a very brave game to be playing with under 18months to go on his contract 

[TheoBair14]

Someone I’d like to see Motherwell sign is Callum Morrison from Falkirk.

[well_said]

14 minutes ago, TheoBair14 said:

Someone I’d like to see Motherwell sign is Callum Morrison from Falkirk.

Not a regular in the Falkirk team that play in a lower division.

[fizoxy]

1 hour ago, TheoBair14 said:

Someone I’d like to see Motherwell sign is Callum Morrison from Falkirk.

Seems ton have had sporadic appearances and has asked to be transferred, presumably because he's not getting game time.