Aberdeen

[Andy_P]

Your thoughts folks......

[Bill Bones]

It'll be interesting to hear what those at the game think.

[Yir Elder]

I know I only followed it on the radio, but Crags sounded like a rock at the back for us, so he gets my vote.

[Malky79]

lol aye who is voting based on radio commentry? Particularly given how poor likes of Scott Davie tend to be?

[Bill Bones]

Jim O'Brien gets the nod on the radio

[nethertonwellfan]

I don't think it is fair for me to vote. I wasn't at the game and never saw any pictures! What game is on BBc alba? I would watch that and make a choice if it was on otherwise it will be a null vote from me.

[Andy_P]

lol aye who is voting based on radio commentry? Particularly given how poor likes of Scott Davie tend to be?

 

Each to their own I suppose.

 

Personally I'll only vote if I've been to a game - or seen it on the telly or a decent quality stream.

 

But if someone feels they've got enough of a feel for the game by listening to the radio and wants to vote then they're fully entitled to.

[Yir Elder]

lol aye who is voting based on radio commentry? Particularly given how poor likes of Scott Davie tend to be?

 

Fair point, but considering we did a lot of defending over the 90 minutes and kept a clean sheet you'd expect it to be one of the back four who'd be our MOTM. Going by what I heard it seemed Crags was solid and won everything in the air.

 

Sure more will vote for him, but if not you can null my vote!!!

[Brazilian]

What game is on BBc alba?

 

Dundee Utd v Falkirk from the bbc Alba website

[nethertonwellfan]

Dundee Utd v Falkirk from the bbc Alba website

Cheers how lazy was I? Sorry Mine is a null vote then..

And null vote is storming into an early lead

[bigcol]

How well did the new boy play up front ?

[studos]

IMHO if you've not actually seen the game you can't give an honest assessment of who you consider to be MOTM.

[SuperSteelman]

IMHO if you've not actually seen the game you can't give an honest assessment of who you consider to be MOTM.

IMHO you can and i'm just about to vote.

[nethertonwellfan]

IMHO you can and i'm just about to vote.

Just copying Radio Scotland

[studos]

IMHO you can and i'm just about to vote.

 

So you are basing your assessment on Scott Davie's commentary. Jeez oh

[Stu]

Craigan, just, for me. Coke a very close second. Coke looked calm and collected throughout and was easily the stand-out in our midfield. However, with the 2nd half belonging to Aberdeen, Craigan did excellently to clear the lines time after time.

[Stu]

How well did the new boy play up front ?

Personally thought he did alright. Put himself about and put in a decent shift. He did miss our best chance, however. Putting a glancing header wide which he probably should have put away...

[mwellhighland]

Cheers how lazy was I? Sorry Mine is a null vote then..

And null vote is storming into an early lead

 

 

You shouldn't choose null vote if you weren't at the game, click show results instead. Null vote should be used for those at the game who thought nobody deserved the title of man of the match

 

That's you telt

[nethertonwellfan]

You shouldn't choose null vote if you weren't at the game, click show results instead. Null vote should be used for those at the game who thought nobody deserved the title of man of the match

 

That's you telt

Point taken. However, I don't think I was the only one who chose null vote and weren't at the game

[TheLip69]

You shouldn't choose null vote if you weren't at the game, click show results instead. Null vote should be used for those at the game who thought nobody deserved the title of man of the match

 

That's what I did and saw Null Vote had 12 votes, for one second I thought we had a new signing.

A big Icelandic full back, possibly.

[trainbus]

Craigan for me. He was solid in the 2nd half when we came close to throwing it away

[Sweeney]

I thought Craigan played great, went for him.

 

Special mentions to Giles Coke and Jim O'Brien though. Coke was excellent and provided some much needed composure in the second half.

[Guest]

Craigan for me, I thought he was immense today. Close between him, J O'B and Coke though. All three put in a cracking performance.

[jk2205]

Coke for me, although Craigan was excellent

[trafficlight]

Sometimes you can get an idea of outstanding performances from radio e.g Ruddy's debut when it was obvious he was brilliant, but in a game like today's it's much more difficult. After listening to the entire match, I haven't a clue to be honest